Their bulging eyes and sweet, crinkled faces may just melt your heart. Before welcoming either one of these pint-sized pups into your home, you’ll want to understand the two breeds’ temperaments, health risks, exercise levels, and puppy prices before settling on the perfect pet.
If you’re in the market for a new dog or just find yourself wondering about the differences between these two popular small breed dogs, you’ve come to the right place. Here, we’ll give you more background about each dog so that you can make an informed decision.
Warmhearted, Steadfast, Fun
$1,000 and Up
Lively, Stubborn, Intelligent
$1,200 to $2,500
To understand what a dog is like today, you need to know about its history. Both breeds have rich accounts that have formed them into the dogs we know and love in current times. Because each of these pups was bred for different reasons, they have certain traits that they still possess today. To understand their background a bit better, let’s take a look at the origins of both breeds.
The Pug has a rich history dating back to the Han Dynasty in China, where they held a royal status. It was not unlikely for Pugs to have servants and receive ranks during this time. However, back then, the breed was known as the Sichuan Pai dog. It wasn’t until the dog reached Western Europe that the name transformed into Pug.
Before reaching Western Europe, the breed spread throughout the Orient because of the widespread trade. The Dutch East India Trading Company, in particular, would bring Pugs back from the trade as precious cargo leading to its increased popularity in the Netherlands.
From Holland, the breed traveled with William and Mary of Orange to assume the monarchy in England. Upon arrival in England among the royal court, the Pug ignited widespread fascination. Eventually, the Sichuan Pai dog dropped its name to become the dog we know and love today.
Dogfighting today is cruel, outlawed, and frowned upon, but that wasn’t the case during 19th century England. Dogfighting, or blood-sport, drew large crowds, spread in popularity, and incited mania for crossbreeding terriers and bull-breeds in hopes to create the ultimate fighting dog. Unfortunately, the crossbreeding for dogfighting in England led to the creation of the breed.
The original dog was a cross between a typical Bulldog and the white English terrier, which is now extinct. The result? A muscular, compact dog named Judge. Eventually, a man named William O’Brien purchased Judge and brought him home to Boston in the United States. Once in Boston, a man named Robert C. Hooper purchased Judge.
With Hooper, Judge became formally known as “Hooper’s Judge” and became the breed’s bloodline patriarch as the prominent ancestor. With Judge’s passed down genetics, his poise, disposition, and prestigious looking black and white coat came about; thus, the breed earned the nickname “the American Gentleman.”
Throughout the early 1900s, the breed ranked among the most popular household dogs in the United States. While not as popular, they still remain a popular breed today.
Small in stature, compact, bulging bug eyes, and wrinkle clad faces, both breeds share quite a few appearance similarities. Based on facial features, the two breeds appear related. When you look more closely at the animals wholly, you’ll see that they differ significantly.
One of the main differences between both dog breeds is their size. Bostons stand taller at around 15 to 17 inches because of its long legs while smaller breeds. The Pug, on the other hand, stands a few inches shorter at around 10 to 13 inches.
While Pugs appear a bit chubby because of their rolls and height, Bostons weigh, on average, more. They can weigh anywhere from 12 to 25 pounds, while the Pug weighs between 14 and 18 pounds.
The breeds’ coats also differ in appearance. The Pug can come in either black or tan, and in some rare occurrences can be white. Boston Terriers come in various colors, all of which contain a white-based coloring. They can also have a brindle colored coat. The most popular and apparent shade for Bostons is the well-known black, and white tuxedo look.
Another, more minute detail is the breeds’ tails. The Pug has a short, curled pig-like tail, but Bostons have a clipped, very short, nubby tail.
People consider dogs man’s best friend because they are friendly and loving animals that make great companions. Both of these family-friendly canines are no exception to this. They both ooze friendliness and love company.
The Pug finds comfort no matter where they live and often enjoys lounging around the house, fun playtimes, and hanging around other people and dogs. They also do well in multi-pet households if raised in them from a young age, and are socialized early.
Similarly, Bostons adapt to their living situation, whether that’s a tight apartment or a vast, open ranch. They have a bit more energy of the two different breeds. While they can lounge around with you all day, they also enjoy getting out and about for playtime. They are also quite amusing because of their playful nature. Their entertaining character makes it a funny little friend to have around.
Boston Terriers vocalize a bit more of the two breeds. While not consistently yappy, they are known to bark more frequently, which can be annoying for those living in tighter living quarters or apartments.
No dog is content sleeping around all day, every day, but the Pug comes close. The Pug’s agreeable and eager to please nature makes it the ideal snuggle buddy for days where you want nothing more than to binge-watch movies all day.
As much as you may want to, keeping your Pug inside all day with nothing to do but sleep isn’t great for its physical and mental health. Pugs still require a substantial amount of playtime during the day to keep them active, fit, and happy. You won’t have to jog them around the block, or throw the ball for them endlessly, but engage in some light playtime throughout the day.
Both dog breeds don’t require an extensive amount of exercise, especially since they no longer participate in dog fights like their ancestors. They do need some exercise, though, some more than others. Both dogs will behave better if taken for brisk walks at least once or twice during the day.
Letting your Boston Terrier out into the yard to run on its own won’t do the trick either. If you let them outside to blow off steam, go with them; otherwise, they’ll wait for you to come out or let them inside. Ignoring their activity needs will only result in resentment or destructive behavior, and the last thing you want or need is your dog to tear up your furniture.
Having been bred for sport, Boston Terriers are eager to please and enjoys a bit of competition. Because of this nature, they take to training with relative ease, especially regarding speed or agility skills.
Both dog breeds are rather sensitive. The Breeds can sense harsh or crude language, rather than stand their ground or succumb to stubbornness; they grow sad and reluctant. Pugs are also known to be less intelligent than other breeds. For both pups, you’d do well to reinforce their training either with treats or positive praise.
During training, Bostons will also benefit from the warmth and gentle corrections. If they mess up a skill or don’t fully grasp a training concept, gently nudge them in the right direction with kind words and positivity. A little kindness will go a long way in training.
As for socialization, both breeds will do well with training sessions early on. You want your dog to develop into a well-mannered, friendly dog, and you can achieve this through socialization.
Ease the dog into social settings, whether with other dogs, other people, or both. Don’t rush them into it. As they get the hang of the training, you can increase their exposure frequency until they’re entirely comfortable with people, dogs, and strangers alike.
While both dog breeds charm their owners and spectators with their large, glossy eyes, their eyes can attract serious health conditions such as cataracts, Cherry Eye, corneal ulcers, and dry eye. Because of these potential risks, you need to monitor and check-up on their eyes frequently.
Pugs, because of their love of food, have the potential to become obese. When considering their food, you should monitor your Pug’s caloric intake, weight, and activity levels to maintain a healthy lifestyle.
Bostons, however, are prone to a few more health risks, specifically deafness. They have large, pointy ears similar to those of French Bulldogs. Due to their size and proportion, they have an increased likelihood of becoming deaf in one or both ears during their lifetime.
All breeds of dogs require a balanced diet to maintain and achieve optimal health; therefore, a balanced diet is necessary for both breeds. They need the appropriate levels of minerals, vitamins, fats, proteins, and carbohydrates, depending on their size.
Since Pugs love to eat and have an increased likelihood of obesity, you need to watch out for your Pug’s caloric intake, including the level of fat in their diet and the number of treats they get in a day. Monitoring their weight and activity level will help inform you of how much food they require. Making sure they are eating a dog food formula made for Pugs and their nutritional needs is essential.
While Boston Terriers are the less likely of the two to become obese, becoming overweight is still probable. Since you don’t want your dog to become overweight and unhealthy, you should monitor its food intake as well. Since Bostons require a bit more activity, look for a more calorie-dense dog food formulated for Boston Terriers.
The level and frequency of grooming depend on your dog’s fur. If the dog’s coat is thicker or longer, then it requires more attention. The Pug, for instance, sheds often. As a result, the Pug requires weekly brushing and would benefit from special shedding tools such as a grooming mitt.
However, just because Pugs need frequent brushing doesn’t mean it needs regular baths. They rarely needs to be given baths. Only bathe your Pug as you see fit, whether it messed up its coat rolling around in something outside or looks a little too weathered.
Boston Terriers require very little maintenance, even less so than the Pug. Its short coat rarely sheds, so you won’t have to worry about tedious brushing routines. The terrier’s coat length also means that it won’t require baths too often, but rather only as you see fit, similar to a Pug’s bathing needs.
The price of any dog, no matter the breed, really depends on where you live, where or who you buy from, and the breed’s popularity at the time of purchase. Typically, purebred puppies of both breeds cost about the same amount with a similar price range of anywhere between $1,000 and $2,500.
With both dog breeds, you can expect to pay more if you are buying from a breeder that has championship lines. This is more common for people that plan to show their dogs. You may also pay a little more if your pup has a unique color combination that other dogs don’t have.
Even if you adopt your pup, the price for each breed remains close in range. However, the price for each breed will increase or decrease depending on the dog’s lineage.
If you’re looking for a small, sweet puppy to bring home, you can’t go wrong with either breed since both breeds make great family additions. While the choice is yours alone for which breed you choose, you should consider the differences between them.
They are both relatively low maintenance dogs, both content to laze around the house and revel in the company of other people and dogs. Boston Terriers requires even less maintenance than the Pug, since they don’t require tedious grooming habits; however, they need a bit more exercise.
Overall, their amusing energy levels combined with their content-to-cuddle character makes these dogs an ideal playmate and lazy day lounging buddy for you and the whole family to love.